Product Filter

Best Selling Candy

  1. Home
  2. Best Selling Candy
  3. Peanut Butter
Filter by
Filter by

84 products found in Best Selling Candy

Quick View
Reese's Big Cup w/ Caramel King Size 2.8oz Pouch
  • From $2.99
Quick View C3 3.5 oz. Chocolate Bar - Peanut Butter Banana - Sweets and Geeks
C3 Peanut Butter Banana 3.5oz Bar (SNG12)
  • $5.99
Quick View Reese's Big Cup W/ Reese's Puffs 1.2oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Big Cup w/ Reese's Puffs 1.2oz Pouch
  • From $1.49
Quick View COOKIE DOUGH BITES - Sweets and Geeks
Cookie Dough Bites Peanut Butter 3oz Theater Box (SNG12)
  • $1.99
Quick View M&M Peanut Butter Stand up Peg Bag 9.6oz - Sweets and Geeks
M&M Peanut Butter Stand up Peg Bag 9oz (SNG8)
  • $7.99
Quick View BUTTERFINGER MINIS THEATER BOX - Sweets and Geeks
Butterfinger Unwrapped Minis 2.8oz Theater Box (SNG9)
  • $1.99
Quick View
Reese's Sugar Free Peanut Butter Cups 3oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $3.99
Quick View Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter 1lb 2oz Jar - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter 18oz Jar (SNG12)
  • $3.99
Quick View Awake Caffeinated Chocolate Bites - Peanut Butter - Sweets and Geeks
Awake Caffeinated Peanut Butter Chocolate Bites 0.4oz Pouch
  • From $1.25
Quick View
Reese's Big Cup Chocolate Lava King Size 2.8oz Pouch
  • From $2.99
Quick View Reese's Minis Unwrapped King Size 2.5oz Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Minis Unwrapped King Size 2.5oz Pouch
  • From $2.99
Quick View
Reese's Big Cup King Size 2.8oz Pouch
  • From $1.99
Quick View
Reese's Sticks King Size 3oz Bar
  • From $2.99
Quick View Sweets N Geeks Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge - Sweets and Geeks
Sweets N Geeks Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge 7oz (SNG12)
  • $5.99
Quick View Atkinson Mary Jane 3oz Peg Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Mary Jane 3oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $1.99
Quick View
Reese's Big Cup Chocolate Lava 1.4oz Pouch
  • From $1.99
Quick View Reese's Crunchy Peanut Bar- King Size - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Crunchy Peanut King Size 3.2oz Bar
  • From $2.99

Sold out

Quick View Munch Peanut Bar - Sweets and Geeks
Munch Peanut Bar 1.4oz Pouch
  • From $1.99
Quick View CHICK-O-STICK NUGGETS PEG BAG SUGARFREE - Sweets and Geeks
Chick-O-Stick Sugar Free Nuggets 3.7oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $3.49
Quick View
M&M Mega Peanut Butter Share Size 2.8oz Pouch
  • From $2.99
Quick View
Reese's Big Cup w/ Caramel 1.4oz Pouch
  • From $1.49
Quick View Reese Miniature Cups 4.6oz Peg Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Reese Miniature Cups 4.6oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $3.49
Quick View
Reese's PB & J Strawberry Big Cup King Size 2.8oz Pouch
  • From $2.99
Quick View Reese's Cups Minis Unwrapped Stand-Up Bag 7.6oz - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Minis Unwrapped 7.6oz Stand Up Bag (SNG8)
  • $7.99
Quick View
Reese's PB & J Grape Big Cup King Size 2.8oz Pouch
  • From $2.99
Quick View
Reese's Fast Break Super King Size 5.25oz Bar
  • From $3.99
Quick View
Reese's Big Cup PB & J Grape 1.4oz Pouch
  • From $1.49
Quick View
Just the Fun Milk Chocolate & Peanut Butter Waffle Cones 4oz Peg Bag (SNG6)
  • $7.99