Product Filter

Best Selling Candy

  1. Home
  2. Best Selling Candy
  3. Peanut Butter
Filter by
Filter by

84 products found in Best Selling Candy

Quick View Atkinson Sugar Free Peg Bag Peanut Butter Bars 3.75oz - Sweets and Geeks
Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars 3.75oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $2.99
Quick View
Reese's Big Cup PB & J Strawberry 1.4oz Pouch
  • From $1.49
Quick View
M&M Peanut Butter & Jelly Share Size 2.83oz Pouch
  • From $2.99
Quick View Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Thins 7.37oz Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Thins 7.37oz Pouch (SNG8)
  • $7.99
Quick View
M&M Mega Peanut Butter 8oz Share Bag (SNG8)
  • $7.99
Quick View
Reese's Pieces King Size 3oz Pouch
  • From $2.99
Quick View
M&M Peanut Butter & Jelly 1.63oz Pouch
  • From $1.99
Quick View
Butterfinger Unwrapped Minis 8oz Stand Up Bag (SNG12)
  • $5.99
Quick View M&M's Classic Mix Share Size 2.5oz - Sweets and Geeks
M&M's Classic Mix Share Size 2.5oz
  • From $2.99
Quick View
Skippy Wafer Peanut Butter & Chocolate 1.3oz Bar
  • From $1.99

Sold out

Quick View
Atkinson's Crunchy Peanut Butter Bars
  • From $0.50

Sold out

Quick View
Skippy Wafer Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly 1.3oz Bar
  • From $1.99
Quick View
Mr Beast Feastables Peanut Butter - 2.11 oz bar
  • From $3.49

Sold out

Quick View Flipz Peanut Butter Flavored Filled Pretzels 6oz Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Flipz Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Filled Pretzels 6oz Peg Bag (SNG8)
  • $4.99
Quick View
Royal Family Peanut Butter Mochi 6.34oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $4.49

Sold out

Quick View
Reese's Sticks King Size 4pc 12oz
  • From $10.99
Quick View
Skippy Chocolate Peanut Butter 1.5oz Bar
  • From $1.99
Quick View
M&M Peanut Butter & Jelly 8.6oz Pouch (SNG8)
  • $7.99

Sold out

Quick View
Reese's Big Cup W/ Caramel Snack Size 5-.55oz Cups
  • From $1.99
Quick View
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie Miniature Cups 9.6oz Stand Up Bag (SNG8)
  • $7.99
Quick View
Reese's Pieces Bark w/Peanuts 3.08oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $3.49
Quick View
Muddy Bites Peanut Butter Chocolate 2.3oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $4.99
Quick View
M&M Peanut Butter 5.1oz Peg Bag (SNG12)
  • $3.49
Quick View
Flipz Peanut Butter Fudge Covered Pretzels 4.3oz Stand Up Pouch (SNG6)
  • $3.99
Quick View
Ass Kickin' Peanut Butter 13oz Tub (SNG12-1)
  • $9.99
Quick View Mary Jane 160ct Tub 20oz - Sweets and Geeks
Mary Jane 160ct 20oz Tub
  • $14.99
Quick View Taffy Town PB&J 2.5lbs Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Taffy Town Peanut Butter and Jelly 2.5lbs Bag
  • $12.99

Sold out

Quick View Taffy Town Peanut Butter 2.5lbs Bag - Sweets and Geeks
Taffy Town Peanut Butter 2.5lbs Bag
  • $12.99